A Brief Discussion of Vanguard’s Alpha and Morningstar’s Gamma

This paper was written for educational purposes only. It must not be construed as the rendering of investment, tax, retirement, estate or risk planning advice. Please do not take action on anything that you read in any of our whitepapers, or anything that is mentioned in our classes, before first discussing it with your investment, tax, retirement, estate and risk planning advisors. All Rights Reserved.

Vanguard’s Alpha

Vanguard is one of the world’s largest investment organizations. Vanguard works with millions of individual investors plus thousands of fee-only wealth managers. Over the past 18 years, Vanguard has been quantifying the value that clients receive when working with “good wealth managers.” Vanguard uses the term Alpha to describe the additional investment return that wealth managers may create for their clients when they adhere to the Vanguard Framework of Good Wealth Management.

Of course, the increase in a client’s investment return is not guaranteed. Client results will vary based on several factors, including the wealth manager’s expertise and the client’s financial behavior.

1. Asset Allocation

A portfolio’s asset allocation is the distribution of money across different asset classes (stocks, bonds, real estate, etc.) and within asset classes (U.S. vs. international stocks, large vs. small-cap, value vs. growth, etc.). According to Vanguard, asset allocation is the most important determinant of a portfolio’s risk and return.

Potential added value: Significant, but too unique to quantify.

2. Asset Class Rebalancing

Over time, asset classes grow at different rates, causing portfolios to drift from their intended allocation. Good wealth managers rebalance portfolios periodically.

Potential added value: Approximately 0.35% per year.

3. Asset Location

Asset location refers to deciding which investments should be held in taxable, tax-deferred, or tax-free accounts.

Potential added value: Approximately 0.75% per year.

4. Cost-Effective Investment Implementation

Vanguard’s research shows that lowering investment costs improves overall returns. Good wealth managers select low-cost index funds and ETFs.

Potential added value: Approximately 0.40% per year.

5. Account Withdrawal Order

Retirees often hold assets across multiple account types with different tax treatments. Good wealth managers determine the optimal order of withdrawals.

Potential added value: Approximately 1.10% per year.

6. Total-Return Investing

Most retirees are better served by investing for total return, combining interest, dividends, and capital gains rather than relying only on income distributions.

Potential added value: Significant but too personalized to quantify.

7. Behavioral Financial Coaching

Investing is emotional. Good wealth managers help clients avoid behavioral mistakes such as buying high and selling low.

Potential added value: Approximately 1.50% per year.

Summary

¹ Additional return is significant but unique to each investor.
² Returns are not guaranteed and vary by advisor expertise and client behavior.

Morningstar’s Gamma

Morningstar is the world’s largest provider of financial analytical reports. Over the past 18 years, Morningstar has been quantifying the value that good wealth managers may provide through optimal retirement planning decisions rather than investment-only decisions.

Morningstar uses the term Gamma to describe the value that “good wealth managers” may create. According to Morningstar, optimal retirement planning decisions may increase a client’s cumulative lifetime retirement income by 20% or more.

Of course, results are not guaranteed.

1. Withdrawing Money from Company-Sponsored Retirement Plans

When retiring, individuals may choose between lump-sum distributions or pension annuities.

Lump-Sum Options:

1. Take the distribution and pay ordinary income taxes.
2. Roll over to an IRA to defer taxes.
3. Use Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) rules for company stock, then pay taxes or roll over the balance.

Pension Annuity Options:

1. Straight Life Annuity: Income stops at death.
2. Life & Refund Certain: Income for life; remaining principal paid to a beneficiary.
3. Life & Period Certain: Beneficiary continues receiving payments until a specified period ends.
4. Joint & Survivor Annuity: Payments continue as long as one spouse is alive.
5. Joint & Survivor with Refund Certain: Beneficiaries receive payments until the full principal is returned.

2. Claiming Social Security Retirement Income Benefits

There are dozens of ways to claim Social Security benefits. Optimal planning can increase lifetime income by $150,000 or more.

3. Determining Retirement Spending

Step 1: Estimate Initial Spending

1. Replacement Rate Models: Typically 75–85% of pre-retirement income.
2. Expense Models: Break spending into essential and non-essential categories.

Step 2: Project Spending Over Time

1. Constant Spending Model: Spending stays steady (adjusted for inflation).
2. Stages of Retirement Model: “Go-go,” “slow-go,” and “no-go” phases.

4. Determining Amount of Investment Withdrawals

1. Percentage of Starting Balance
2. Percentage with Inflation Adjustment
3. Percentage with Inflation + Market Adjustment

5. Taking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)

• Choosing the first distribution year (deadline: April 1 following age 70½).
• Selecting the correct IRS life expectancy table.

6. Making IRA Distributions to Surviving Beneficiaries

• Should a spouse roll over or use an inherited IRA?
• Should children use inherited IRAs?
• Should a Stretch Trust be used?

Please remember that we have only briefly discussed just six of the many retirement planning issues that require optimal decisions.

Please contact us to learn more.